Quartz or calcite? Hardness, streak, and the acid test

Advertisement
Crystal Cave Minerals OP
1 month, 3 weeks ago
#1
A recurring question in the shop, so let's pin down the basics. Quartz is hardness 7 and will scratch glass; calcite is hardness 3 and is scratched by a copper coin. Calcite has three good cleavages and reacts with dilute acid (even vinegar) with a fizz; quartz does not. Under UV, many calcites fluoresce while quartz is usually inert. Streak is white for both, so it is not diagnostic. What field tests do you trust most before a specimen reaches the lab?
Desert Stones
1 month, 3 weeks ago
#2
A drop of 5% vinegar is my go-to. If it fizzes, I stop there. Also check double refraction: a clear calcite rhomb prints doubled text.
Mica Fan
1 month, 3 weeks ago
#3
Thermal feel helps with big rough pieces - calcite feels noticeably warmer or cooler to the touch than quartz, though it is subjective.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to reply to this discussion.

Sign In to Reply